Harry Douglas: the Vikings' QB room is 'very awkward.' He has a point.
The incumbent starter is competing against a $30 million Plan B for his own job in front of his own teammates. McCarthy says it's fine. Outside observers are less sure.
ESPN's Harry Douglas called the Vikings' quarterback room 'very awkward' on First Take Thursday, the same day J.J. McCarthy told reporters there wasn't any awkwardness at all. Both assessments can be true at the same time. What the Vikings built is genuinely unusual.
Why did Douglas call it awkward?
The basic structure: a second-year starter is competing for his job against a Pro Bowl veteran the team acquired specifically because the starter's year-one performance wasn't good enough to close the competition. McCarthy is the incumbent. Murray is the insurance policy that got elevated to a genuine threat. Douglas, a former receiver who played with multiple starting quarterbacks during his career, argued that the dynamic is difficult to manage regardless of how professional both players are about it publicly.
What makes this situation different from a normal QB competition?
Most QB competitions involve an established starter and a younger player developing behind him, or two unknowns competing for a new job. The Vikings' room is neither. McCarthy started last season, went 35.6 QBR in the first half, improved significantly late, and then watched the team bring in Kyler Murray on a one-year deal worth $1.3 million to compete with him. Murray is older, more experienced, and was brought in specifically because the front office wasn't comfortable handing the job outright to McCarthy. The receivers in the huddle know all of this. So do the linemen.
What does McCarthy's late-season improvement actually mean?
In his final four starts, McCarthy posted a 69.8 QBR and the team went 3-1. That's a legitimate data point. It's also four games, against a schedule that wasn't particularly strong defensively. The Vikings finished 11-6 and lost in the divisional round. The question the front office was apparently unable to answer conclusively was whether the late-season McCarthy was the real McCarthy or a hot streak. The Murray signing is the answer: they don't know yet, and they wanted a contingency.
Who does the situation favor?
On paper, incumbents win most legitimate QB competitions. The starter has the relationships, the rep count, and the coaching staff's investment. McCarthy has all of that. But Murray threw the two best passes at Wednesday's OTA session and has a track record of two 10-plus-win seasons in Arizona. If the competition stays genuinely open through training camp, the external pressure on McCarthy increases every week. The uncomfortable version of this situation is that both players perform well and Kevin O'Connell has to make an actual decision in August.
Players in this story
Sources
- ESPN: Douglas: Vikings QB room is 'very awkward' with McCarthy, Murray
- ESPN: McCarthy: No 'awkwardness' with Murray over QB1 competition
Minnesota Vikings betting odds
Super Bowl futures, win totals & where to bet
21+ and present in a state where legal. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. We may earn a commission.
