Keon Coleman calls 2026 'make or break' as the Bills crowd their WR room
The 2024 second-round pick is fourth on the depth chart after Buffalo traded for DJ Moore and signed Joshua Palmer.
Keon Coleman stood at his locker after Tuesday's OTA session and gave reporters one of the more honest self-assessments of the offseason. 'For me, it's make or break,' he said. The 2024 No. 33 overall pick is going into year three with the Bills having reshuffled the WR room around him.
What's Coleman's production been so far?
Across two seasons: 67 receptions, 960 receiving yards, 8 TDs. Decent for a WR3 or WR4. Well short of the production scouts projected when the Bills traded up to take him at 33rd overall. His 2025 second-half breakout (he caught 1,020 yards across the full season) suggested he could be the long-term WR1. The offseason additions tell a different story.
Who is ahead of him on the depth chart?
DJ Moore (acquired from Chicago for a 2026 third), Khalil Shakir (signed to a $52 million extension in March), and Joshua Palmer (free-agent signing from the Chargers). Coleman is the projected fourth receiver, with rookie Skyler Bell from UConn pushing for snaps behind him. Three of those names came in during the past three months.
What did head coach Joe Brady say?
Brady (the former Bills OC who got the head coaching job after Sean McDermott's January firing) defended Coleman without overselling him. 'I made sure when I got the job he knew he was going to be here and be a part of our offense,' Brady said. 'He's a young player who has shown flashes. We need to put him in spots where his strengths show up every snap, not just sometimes.'
Why is this a 'make or break' year?
Two reasons. First, the Bills hold a fifth-year option decision on Coleman's contract by May 2027. A subpar 2026 makes that decline near-certain, which would put him in free agency at age 24 with limited leverage. Second, the WR room now has four veteran starters and a rookie pushing for time. Coleman has to win his snaps on production, not on draft status.
What does success look like for him in 2026?
Buffalo's depth chart suggests 55 to 70 catches for 800 to 950 yards as the second perimeter receiver. Eight-plus touchdowns. The Bills' offense ran for 3,200 yards in 2025 and Josh Allen's pass volume sits in the bottom third of the league. Coleman's path is volume efficiency: high TD rate, high catch rate, big plays on the limited targets he sees. Hit those marks and Buffalo picks up the option. Miss them and the writing is on the wall.
Players in this story
Sources
- NFL.com: Bills WR Keon Coleman describes 2026 season as 'make or break'
- Yahoo Sports: Coleman says 2026 season is 'make or break' for his Bills career
- Buffalo Bills: OTA Notebook on Joe Brady and Keon Coleman
- Heavy: Joe Brady reveals Bills' plan for Keon Coleman this season
Buffalo Bills betting odds
Super Bowl futures, win totals & where to bet
21+ and present in a state where legal. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. We may earn a commission.
